Create new or update existing entity at one go with JPA

Posted by Alex R on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Alex R
Published on 2010-02-25T18:21:22Z Indexed on 2010/03/08 9:06 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 261

Filed under:
|

A have a JPA entity that has timestamp field and is distinguished by a complex identifier field. What I need is to update timestamp in an entity that has already been stored, otherwise create and store new entity with the current timestamp.

As it turns out the task is not as simple as it seems from the first sight. The problem is that in concurrent environment I get nasty "Unique index or primary key violation" exception. Here's my code:

// Load existing entity, if any.
Entity e = entityManager.find(Entity.class, id);
if (e == null) {
  // Could not find entity with the specified id in the database, so create new one.
  e = entityManager.merge(new Entity(id));
}
// Set current time...
e.setTimestamp(new Date());
// ...and finally save entity.
entityManager.flush();

Please note that in this example entity identifier is not generated on insert, it is known in advance.

When two or more of threads run this block of code in parallel, they may simultaneously get null from entityManager.find(Entity.class, id) method call, so they will attempt to save two or more entities at the same time, with the same identifier resulting in error.

I think that there are few solutions to the problem.

  1. Sure I could synchronize this code block with a global lock to prevent concurrent access to the database, but would it be the most efficient way?
  2. Some databases support very handy MERGE statement that updates existing or creates new row if none exists. But I doubt that OpenJPA (JPA implementation of my choice) supports it.
  3. Event if JPA does not support SQL MERGE, I can always fall back to plain old JDBC and do whatever I want with the database. But I don't want to leave comfortable API and mess with hairy JDBC+SQL combination.
  4. There is a magic trick to fix it using standard JPA API only, but I don't know it yet.

Please help.

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about jpa

Related posts about insert-update