How to create a variadic (with variable length argument list) function wrapper in JavaScript
Posted
by U-D13
on Stack Overflow
See other posts from Stack Overflow
or by U-D13
Published on 2010-03-18T19:18:59Z
Indexed on
2010/03/18
19:21 UTC
Read the original article
Hit count: 457
The intention is to build a wrapper to provide a consistent method of calling native functions with variable arity on various script hosts - so that the script could be executed in a browser as well as in the Windows Script Host or other script engines.
I am aware of 3 methods of which each one has its own drawbacks.
eval()
method:function wrapper () { var str = ''; for (var i=0; i<arguments.lenght; i++) str += (str ?', ':'') + ',arguments['+i+']'; return eval('[native_function] ('+str+')'); }
switch()
method:function wrapper () { switch (arguments.lenght) { case 0: return [native_function] (arguments[0]); break; case 1: return [native_function] (arguments[0], arguments[1]); break; ... case n: return [native_function] (arguments[0], arguments[1], ... arguments[n]); } }
apply()
method:function wrapper () { return [native_function].apply([native_function_namespace], arguments); }
What's wrong with them you ask?
Well, shall we delve into all the reasons why
eval()
is evil? And also all the string concatenation... Not a solution to be labeled "elegant".One can never know the maximum
n
and thus how manycases
to prepare. This also would strech the script to immense proportions and sin against the holy DRY principle.The script could get executed on older (pre- JavaScript 1.3 / ECMA-262-3) engines that don't support the
apply()
method.
Now the question part: is there any another solution out there?
© Stack Overflow or respective owner