Why does defined(X) not work in a preprocessor definition without a space?

Posted by Devin on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Devin
Published on 2010-03-19T21:20:48Z Indexed on 2010/03/19 21:31 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 131

Filed under:

c++

|

msvc

A preprocessor definition that includes defined(X) will never evaluate to true, but (defined X) will. This occurs in MSVC9; I have not tested other preprocessors. A simple example:

#define FEATURE0 1
#define FEATURE1 0
#define FEATURE2 1

#define FEATURE3 (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined(FEATURE2)))
#define FEATURE4 (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined FEATURE2))
#define FEATURE5 (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined (FEATURE2)))

#if FEATURE3
#pragma message("FEATURE3 Enabled")
#elif (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined(FEATURE2)))
#pragma message("FEATURE3 Enabled (Fallback)")
#endif

#if FEATURE4
#pragma message("FEATURE4 Enabled")
#elif (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined FEATURE2))
#pragma message("FEATURE4 Enabled (Fallback)")
#endif

#if FEATURE5
#pragma message("FEATURE5 Enabled")
#elif (FEATURE0 && !FEATURE1 && (defined (FEATURE2)))
#pragma message("FEATURE5 Enabled (Fallback)")
#endif

The output from the compiler is:

1>FEATURE3 Enabled (Fallback)
1>FEATURE4 Enabled
1>FEATURE5 Enabled

Working cases: defined (X), defined( X ), and defined X.
Broken case: defined(X)

Why is defined evaluated differently when part of a definition, as in the #if cases in the example, compared to direct evaluation, as in the #elif cases in the example?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about c++

Which C++ book shold I get between "C++ Primer" vs "C++ Primer Plus"

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I want to learn C++ by using Vim and MinGW as compiler. I'm interesting at "C++ Primer (4th Edition)" and "C++ Primer Plus (5th Edition)" but I don't know how about it different. It has no book store that I can review those books, so I want to know, what is the different between those book and which… >>> More
C++ : C++ Primer (Stanley Lipmann) or The C++ programming language (special edition)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I have a Computer Science degree (long2 time ago) .. I do know Java OOP but i am now trying to pick up C++. I do have C and of course data structure using C or pascal. I have started reading Bjarne Stroustrup book (The C++ Programming Language - Special Edition) but find it extremely difficult esp… >>> More
I need help on my C++ assignment using MS Visual C++

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Ok, so I don't want you to do my homework for me, but I'm a little lost with this final assignment and need all the help I can get. Learning about programming is tough enough, but doing it online is next to impossible for me... Now, to get to the program, I am going to paste what I have so far. This… >>> More
Managed c++ std::string not accessible in unmanaged c++

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
In unmanaged c++ dll i have a function which takes constant std::string as argument Prototype : void read ( const std::string &imageSpec_ ) I call this function from managed c++ dll by passing a std::string. When i debug the unmanaged c++ code the parameter imageSpec_ shows the value correctly… >>> More
The Definitive C++ Book Guide and List

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
After more than a few questions about deciding on C++ books I thought we could make a better community wiki version. Providing QUALITY books and an approximate skill level. Maybe we can add a short blurb/description about each book that you have personally read / benefited from. Feel free to debate… >>> More

Related posts about msvc

Linking to MSVC DLL from MinGW

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm trying to link the LizardTech GeoExpress DSDK into my own application. I use gcc so that we can compile on for platforms. On Linux and Mac this works easily: they provide a static library (libltidsdk.a) and headers and all that we have to do is use them. Compiling for windows isn't so easy… >>> More
Compiling python modules whith DEBUG defined on MSVC

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Python rather stupidly has a pragma directive in its include files that forces a link against python26_d.lib when the DEBUG preprocessor variable is defined. This is a problem because the python installer doesn't come with python26_d.lib! So I can't build applications in msvc in debug mode. If i temporarily… >>> More
Replacement for vsscanf on msvc

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, I've run into an issue porting a codebase from linux (gcc) to windows (msvc). It seems like the C99 function vsscanf isn't available and has no obvious replacement. I've read about a solution using the internal function _input_l and linking statically to the crt runtime, but unfortunately I cannot… >>> More
Program compiled with MSVC 9 won't start on a vanilla SP3 XP

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I installed XP on a virtual machine, updated it to SP3 and then tested a small program compiled with Visual C++ 2008 on my real computer - however it didn't start but outputted only an error saying that a problem had been detected and that a reinstall of the application (mine is 10KB in size and doesn't… >>> More
Portability of pthreads-win32 over various compilers.

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello, I'm using pthreads-win32 for portable threading support for windows. At least, according to the documentation pthreads-win32 should work with MSVC and even MSVC builds provided. But I don't know if the library is tested with latest MSVC compilers like MSVC-2008 and if it is supported under… >>> More