Should I convert my AAC M4A files to MP3?

Posted by j0rd4n on Super User See other posts from Super User or by j0rd4n
Published on 2010-03-20T13:51:47Z Indexed on 2010/03/20 14:01 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 428

Filed under:

mp3

|

m4a

|

aac

|

conversion

|

audio-conversion

Due to Apple, I have a large majority of my music files in the AAC M4A format. They do NOT have DRM so I don't have to worry about that. I'm getting tired of Apple products and really want to switch to a different brand player (and something more compatible with Linux).

It appears most MP3 players support...well...MP3 and not AAC.

Should I convert my library to be free of Apple and open to other players?
Is this a lossless conversion? Can it be lossless? If I will lose quality, I'm not interested.
Am I even doing the right thing? AAC is the better format, but I'm not seeing a lot of support for it yet.

I'll be honest and say that I need some education in this department. Any helpful advice is most welcome.

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about mp3

Concatenating several .mp3 files into one .mp3

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
As it was suggested here I am using cat command to concatenate several .mp3 files into one .mp3 file. Imagine, I have following .mp3 files in the current folder: 001001.mp3 001002.mp3 001003.mp3 001004.mp3 001005.mp3 or, like this: 096001.mp3 096002.mp3 096003.mp3 096004.mp3 I need to concatenate… >>> More
Paperclip validates_attachment_content_type for mp3 triggered when attaching mp3

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hey everyone, Struggling to workout when i add the following validtion to my Voice model using paperclip, it is being triggered when i try and upload an mp3: class Voice < ActiveRecord::Base has_attached_file :clip validates_attachment_presence :clip validates_attachment_content_type :clip… >>> More
concatenating mp3 files or joining mp3 files using java

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
We would like to concatenate/merge/join mp3 files seamlessly using "java" in any environment. We are trying the following options at the moment ( please let us know any other options): Using JMF -- ruled out as it supported only in windows http://java.sun.com/javase/technologies/desktop/media/jmf/reference/faqs/index… >>> More
How To Add MP3 Support to Audacity (to Save in MP3 Format)

as seen on How to geek - Search for 'How to geek'
You may have noticed that the default installation of Audacity doesn’t have built-in support for MP3s due to licensing issues. Here’s how to add it in yourself for free really easily in few simple steps. Photo by bobcat rock Latest Features How-To Geek ETC HTG… >>> More
Converting .wav (CCITT A-Law format) to .mp3 using LAME

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I would like to convert wav files to mp3 using the lame encoder (lame.exe). The wav files are recorded along the following specifications: Bit Rate: 64kbps Audio sample size: 8 bit Channels: 1 (mono) Audio sample rate: 8 kHz Audio format: CCITT A-Law If I try to convert such a wav file using lame… >>> More

Related posts about m4a

Why is my ogg bigger than my m4a?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I am using the following commands to encode an audio file to m4a & ogg formats: ffmpeg.exe -i 0123456789 -ab 192k out.m4a ffmpeg.exe -i 0123456789 -f wav - | oggenc2.exe - -r -q 6 -o out.ogg (0123456789 has no extension.) My m4a output is 14,608kB while my ogg output is 19,809kB. Why? AFAIK… >>> More
Why is my ogg bigger then my m4a?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
i am using ffmpeg.exe -i 0123456789 -ab 192k out.m4a ffmpeg.exe -i 0123456789 -f wav - | oggenc2.exe - -r -q 6 -o out.ogg (0123456789 has no extension). My m4a output is 14,608kb while my ogg output is 19,809kb why? AFAIK -q 6 is roughly 192kb. So it should be about even. I could see one file… >>> More
WPF MediaPlayer doesn't play M4A?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I am trying to use a MediaPlayer instance to play M4A files. For those of you that aren't familiar, MediaPlayer is the non-XAML version of a MediaElement. There are pretty much the same, but I don't want any XAML, so I use a MediaPlayer instead. Anyways, it plays some M4A files just fine. The NaturalDuration… >>> More
What's in a name? .aac V .m4a? aac->Works on website quicktime. m4a->works on iPad

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
What is the difference between an .aac file and an .m4a file? If I just change the file extension of an audio file recorded and then converted into "AAC" between .aac/.m4a it drastically affects how the file is treated. AAC: Plays in a web browser, not on the iPad M4A: Plays on the iPad, not on… >>> More
Is there now any way to convert mp3 files to m4a or aac 192kbit?

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
Since about two years now I am trying to find a way to convert high quality mp3 files to m4a or aac files with a fixed bitrate 192k. Please don't suggest using another format - i thought this through as far as it goes. The problem here is: ffmpeg obvioulsy can't convert to a higher bitrate than… >>> More