why does chkdsk always report errors on a bad shutdown

Posted by rep_movsd on Super User See other posts from Super User or by rep_movsd
Published on 2010-03-24T09:09:14Z Indexed on 2010/03/24 9:13 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 625

Filed under:
|

Once in a while, Windows XP hangs on my laptop (usually when going into standby or hibernate and occasionally on startup) and I have to forcefully poweroff. Ususally chkdsk never runs automatically (I thought it should know that the partitions have nit been unmounted and do that).

I religiously run chkdsk without /F after bad shutdowns like this, and invariably it reports that the drive has unfixed errors and must be checked with /F and I do that, and more often than not, the chdsk that runs on startup does not report fixing anything.

I have had times in the past (and not only just on this system) when not running chkdsk leads to some strange errors like files not opening even though they exist and inability to save certain files, so I make it a point to always chkdsk after bad shutdown.

I never understood why this is : Isnt the whole point of a journalling filesystem like NTFS to avoid file system corruption and endless chkdsks?

I even tried once disabling write caching to see if it made any difference, but to no avail....

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about windows-xp

Related posts about chkdsk