Primary Key Identity Value Increments On Unique Key Constraint Violation

Posted by Jed on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Jed
Published on 2010-03-27T18:04:56Z Indexed on 2010/03/27 18:13 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 533

Filed under:

sql

|

unique

|

key

|

primary

|

violation

I have a SqlServer 2008 table which has a Primary Key (IsIdentity=Yes) and three other fields that make up a Unique Key constraint.

In addition I have a store procedure that inserts a record into the table and I call the sproc via C# using a SqlConnection object.

The C# sproc call works fine, however I have noticed interesting results when the C# sproc call violates the Unique Key constraint....

When the sproc call violates the Unique Key constraint, a SqlException is thrown - which is no surprise and cool. However, I notice that the next record that is successfully added to the table has a PK value that is not exactly one more than the previous record -

For example: Say the table has five records where the PK values are 1,2,3,4, and 5. The sproc attempts to insert a sixth record, but the Unique Key constraint is violated and, so, the sixth record is not inserted. Then the sproc attempts to insert another record and this time it is successful. - This new record is given a PK value of 7 instead of 6.

Is this normal behavior? If so, can you give me a reason why this is so? (If a record fails to insert, why is the PK index incremented?)

If this is not normal behavior, can you give me any hints as to why I am seeing these symptoms?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about sql

SQL SERVER – Concat Strings in SQL Server using T-SQL – SQL in Sixty Seconds #035 – Video

as seen on SQL Authority - Search for 'SQL Authority'
Concatenating string is one of the most common tasks in SQL Server and every developer has to come across it. We have to concat the string when we have to see the display full name of the person by first name and last name. In this video we will see various methods to concatenate the strings. SQL… >>> More
SQL SERVER – Concat Function in SQL Server – SQL Concatenation

as seen on SQL Authority - Search for 'SQL Authority'
Earlier this week, I was delivering Advanced BI training on the subject of “SQL Server 2008 R2″. I had great time delivering the session. During the session, we talked about SQL Server 2010 Denali. Suddenly one of the attendees suggested his displeasure for the product. He said, even though… >>> More
Error with SQL Server Setup 2012 on Windows 2012

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I am trying to install SQL Server on Windows 2012. I was able to finally get the wizard up and running after making some changes on the server, but now it fails no matter what I do with the following error: TITLE: SQL Server Setup failure. SQL Server Setup has encountered the following error: … >>> More
How can I detect which version of SQL (eg SQL 2008 or SQL Azure)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I need to detect which version of SQL I am dealing with to perorm various tasks, I need specifically detect if I am on SQL 2008 or SQL Azure. How can I do this with detection code written in SQL? >>> More
Nested SQL Select statement fails on SQL Server 2000, ok on SQL Server 2005

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Here is the query: INSERT INTO @TempTable SELECT UserID, Name, Address1 = (SELECT TOP 1 [Address] FROM (SELECT TOP 1 [Address] FROM [UserAddress] ua INNER JOIN UserAddressOrder uo ON ua.UserID = uo.UserID WHERE ua.UserID = u.UserID ORDER BY uo.AddressOrder ASC) q ORDER BY AddressOrder… >>> More

Related posts about unique

Hash of unique value = unique hash?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Theoretically does hashing a unique value yield a unique value? Let's say I have a DB table with 2 columns: id and code. id is an auto-incrementing int and code is a varchar. If I do ... $code = sha1($id); ... and then store $code into the same row as $id. Will my code column be unique as well… >>> More
Unique Business Value vs. Unique IT

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
When the age of computing started, technology was new, exciting, full of potential and had a long way to grow. Vendor architectures were proprietary, and limited in function at first, growing in capability and complexity over time. There were few if any "standards", let alone "open standards" and… >>> More
Creating a short unique string for each unique long string

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm trying to create a url shortener system in c# and asp.net mvc. I know about hashtable and I know how to create a redirect system etc. The problem is indexing long urls in database. Some urls may have up to 4000 character length, and it seems it is a bad idea to index this kind of strings. The… >>> More
Return a Unique Bean Instance from a Spring Container

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Define the bean as a prototype bean. >>> More
Return a Unique Bean Instance from a Spring Container

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Define the bean as a prototype bean. >>> More