TDD, DDD and the No-getters principle

Posted by Justin on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Justin
Published on 2009-07-17T20:53:11Z Indexed on 2010/04/28 1:13 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 468

Filed under:

TDD

|

ddd

|

c#

|

getters

Hi all,

After several years of following the bad practice handed down from 'architects' at my place of work and thinking that there must be a better way, I've recently been reading up around TDD and DDD and I think the principles and practices would be a great fit for the complexity of the software we write.

However, many of the TDD samples I have seen call a method on the domain object and then test properties of the object to ensure the behaviour executed correctly.

On the other hand, several respected people in the industry (Greg Young most noticeably so) advocate the "no-getters" principle on our domain objects.

My question therefore is: How does one test the functionality of a domain object if it is forbidden to retrieve its state?

I believe I am missing something fundamental so please feel free to call me an idiot and enlighten me - any guidance would be greatly appreciated.

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about TDD

TDD - How to start really thinking TDD?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I have been reading about Agile, XP methodologies and TDDs. I have been in projects which states it needs to do TDD, but most of the tests are somehow integration tests or during the course of project TDD is forgotten in effort to finish codes faster. So, as far as my case goes, I have written unit… >>> More
Are "TDD Tests" different to Unit Tests?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I read this article about TDD and unit testing: http://stephenwalther.com/blog/archive/2009/04/11/tdd-tests-are-not-unit-tests.aspx I think it was an excellent article. The author makes a distinction between what he calls "TDD Tests" and unit testing. They appear to be different tests to him. Previous… >>> More
Doing TDD Silverlight 4 RC using Visual Studio 2010 RC

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
First I am glad to see better TDD support in VS2010. Support for generating code stubs from my tests is ok - not as good as more mature TDD plug-ins but a good start. I am looking for some best Silverlight 4.0 TDD practices. First Question: Anyone have links, recommendations? I know the new Silverlight… >>> More
Applying Test Driven Development to a tightly coupled architecture

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi all, I've recently been studying TDD, attended a conference and have dabbled in few tests and already I'm 100% sold, I absolutely love it TDD. As a result I've raised this with my seniors and they are prepared to give it a chance, so they have tasked me with coming up with a way to implement… >>> More
Integrating JavaScript Unit Tests with Visual Studio

as seen on Stephen Walter - Search for 'Stephen Walter'
Modern ASP.NET web applications take full advantage of client-side JavaScript to provide better interactivity and responsiveness. If you are building an ASP.NET application in the right way, you quickly end up with lots and lots of JavaScript code. When writing server code, you should be writing… >>> More

Related posts about ddd

Implement DDD and drawing the line between the an Entity and value object

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I am implementing an EMR project. I would like to apply a DDD based approach to the problem. I have identified the "Patient" as being the core object of the system. I understand Patient would be an entity object as well as an aggregrate. I have also identified that every patient must have a… >>> More
DDD with Grails

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I cannot find any info about doing Domain Driven Design (DDD) with Grails. I'm looking for any best practices, experience notes or even open source projects that are good examples of DDD with Grails. >>> More
in DDD (gdb) how to skip passed loops

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
During many, sometimes inundating, debugging sessions using DDD, I stumble upon loops. And I keep pressing next to get passed it, and if there are many iterations, I just set a break point right after it, and press "continue." Is there any other way to go passed loops? Thanks >>> More
in DDD (gdb) how to skip past loops

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
During many, sometimes inundating, debugging sessions using DDD, I stumble upon loops. And I keep pressing next to get past it, and if there are many iterations, I just set a break point right after it, and press "continue." Is there any other way to go past loops? Thanks >>> More
Service Oriented Architecture & Domain-Driven Design

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I've always developed code in a SOA type of way. This year I've been trying to do more DDD but I keep getting the feeling that I'm not getting it. At work our systems are load balanced and designed not to have state. The architecture is: Website ===Physical Layer== Main Service ==Physical Layer== Server… >>> More