Which kind of method signature do you prefer and why?

Posted by devoured elysium on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by devoured elysium
Published on 2010-05-12T16:18:30Z Indexed on 2010/05/12 16:24 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 202

Filed under:

subjective

|

methods

|

.NET

|

c#

Ok, this is probably highly subjective but here it comes:

Let's assume I'm writing a method that will take a printscreen of some region of the screen. Which method signature would you prefer and why?

Bitmap DoPrintScreen(int x, int y, int width, int height);
Bitmap DoPrintScreen(Rectangle rect);
Bitmap DoPrintScreen(Point point, Size size);
Other

Why?

I keep seeing myself repeatedly implementing both 1) and 2) (redirecting one of them to the other) but I end up usually just using one of them, so there really is no point in having both. I can't decide which would be better. Maybe I should use the signature that looks the most with the method I'll be calling to make the printscreen?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about subjective

Scoring/analysis of Subjective testing for skills assessment

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I am lucky in the sense that I have been given the opportunity to be a 'Technical Troubleshooter' for our offshore development team. While I am confident and capable of dealing with most issues, I have come across something that I am not. Based on initial discussions with various team members both… >>> More
Best Practise/Subjective: Implement a finite state automaton in OOP

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi guys, I am thinking about implementing a programm with finite state automaton in an OOP language like Java or C++. What would you think is the best way to implement this with a manageable amount of available states, regarding to good software design? Is it good to implement for each state an… >>> More
Subjective question...would you use the Action delegate to avoid duplication of code?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello, I just asked a question that helps about using generics (or polymorphism) to avoid duplication of code. I am really trying to follow the DRY principle. So I just ran into the following code... Sub OutputDataToExcel() OutputLine("Output DataBlocks", 1) OutputDataBlocks() … >>> More
"Best" language /architecture for browser-based app with ODBC and sockets? (subjective)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Sorry to ask a subjective question, but I would welcome some advice. I am an experienced programmer of embedded s/w, but haven't done much network programming, although I have done a fair bit of hobbyist PHP. Anyway, I have to develop what is probably a fairly general type of app, as shown in this… >>> More
The best terminal emulator for a heavy terminal user?

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I spend a lot of time at the command-line during the workday and at home too since I run Ubuntu exclusively. I've been using the default gnome terminal but I've reached a point where I'd really like to get my terminal tricked out so that my common tasks are as easy as possible. Specifically, I find… >>> More

Related posts about methods

how to differentiate public methods and private methods during api testing

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
is it possible to test private methods of web serive during api testing? if yes how to differentiate public methods and private methods. I am using object browser in VSTS to see the list methods available. >>> More
Action -methods vs public methods in PHP frameworks

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
There are plenty of PHP frameworks out there as many of you know, and I am interested in your thoughts on this: Zend Framework has so-called action controllers that must contain at least one action method, a method whose name ends in "Action". For example: public function indexAction() {} The word… >>> More
Use python decorators on class methods and subclass methods

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Goal: Make it possible to decorate class methods. When a class method gets decorated, it gets stored in a dictionary so that other class methods can reference it by a string name. Motivation: I want to implement the equivalent of ASP.Net's WebMethods. I am building this on top of google app engine… >>> More
Accessing "Public" methods from "Private" methods in javascript class

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Is there a way to call "public" javascript functions from "private" ones within a class? Check out the class below: function Class() { this.publicMethod = function() { alert("hello"); } privateMethod = function() { publicMethod(); } this.test = function() … >>> More
Parsing C#, finding methods and putting try/catch to all methods

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I know it sounds weird but I am required to put a wrapping try catch block to every method to catch all exceptions. We have thousands of methods and I need to do it in an automated way. What do you suggest? I am planning to parse all cs files and detect methods and insert a try catch block with an… >>> More