Best way to close nested streams in Java?
Posted
by dirtyvagabond
on Stack Overflow
See other posts from Stack Overflow
or by dirtyvagabond
Published on 2009-05-19T17:14:31Z
Indexed on
2010/06/09
14:42 UTC
Read the original article
Hit count: 476
What is considered the best, most comprehensive way to close nested streams in Java? For example, consider the setup:
FileOutputStream fos = new FileOutputStream(...)
BufferedOS bos = new BufferedOS(fos);
ObjectOutputStream oos = new ObjectOutputStream(bos);
I understand the close operation needs to be insured (probably by using a finally clause). What I wonder about is, is it necessary to explicitly make sure the nested streams are closed, or is it enough to just make sure to close the outer stream (oos)?
One thing I notice, at least dealing with this specific example, is that the inner streams only seem to throw FileNotFoundExceptions. Which would seem to imply that there's not technically a need to worry about closing them if they fail.
Here's what a colleague wrote:
Technically, if it were implemented right, closing the outermost stream (oos) should be enough. But the implementation seems flawed.
Example: BufferedOutputStream inherits close() from FilterOutputStream, which defines it as:
155 public void close() throws IOException {
156 try {
157 flush();
158 } catch (IOException ignored) {
159 }
160 out.close();
161 }
However, if flush() throws a runtime exception for some reason, then out.close() will never be called. So it seems "safest" (but ugly) to mostly worry about closing FOS, which is keeping the file open.
What is considered to be the hands-down best, when-you-absolutely-need-to-be-sure, approach to closing nested streams?
And are there any official Java/Sun docs that deal with this in fine detail?
© Stack Overflow or respective owner