Taking "do the simplest thing that could possible work" too far in TDD: testing for a file-name kno

Posted by Support - multilanguage SO on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Support - multilanguage SO
Published on 2010-06-09T23:27:45Z Indexed on 2010/06/10 0:12 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 546

For TDD you have to

  1. Create a test that fail
  2. Do the simplest thing that could possible work to pass the test
  3. Add more variants of the test and repeat
  4. Refactor when a pattern emerge

With this approach you're supposing to cover all the cases ( that comes to my mind at least) but I'm wonder if am I being too strict here and if it is possible to "think ahead" some scenarios instead of simple discover them.

For instance, I'm processing a file and if it doesn't conform to a certain format I am to throw an InvalidFormatException

So my first test was:

@Test 
void testFormat(){
    // empty doesn't do anything nor throw anything
    processor.validate("empty.txt"); 
    try {
        processor.validate("invalid.txt");
        assert false: "Should have thrown InvalidFormatException";
    } catch( InvalidFormatException ife ) {
        assert "Invalid format".equals( ife.getMessage() );
    }
 }

I run it and it fails because it doesn't throw an exception.

So the next thing that comes to my mind is: "Do the simplest thing that could possible work", so I :

public void validate( String fileName ) throws InvalidFormatException {
    if(fileName.equals("invalid.txt") {
        throw new InvalidFormatException("Invalid format");
    }
}

Doh!! ( although the real code is a bit more complicated, I found my self doing something like this several times )

I know that I have to eventually add another file name and other test that would make this approach impractical and that would force me to refactor to something that makes sense ( which if I understood correctly is the point of TDD, to discover the patterns the usage unveils ) but:

Q: am I taking too literal the "Do the simplest thing..." stuff?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about best-practices

Related posts about language-agnostic