Defend zero-based arrays

Posted by DrJokepu on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by DrJokepu
Published on 2008-12-26T04:12:05Z Indexed on 2010/06/18 14:43 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 370

Filed under:

arrays

|

language-agnostic

|

discussion

A question asked here recently reminded me of a debate I had not long ago with a fellow programmer. Basically he argued that zero-based arrays should be replaced by one-based arrays since arrays being zero based is an implementation detail that originates from the way arrays and pointers and computer hardware work, but these sort of stuff should not be reflected in higher level languages.

Now I am not really good at debating so I couldn't really offer any good reasons to stick with zero-based arrays other than they sort of feel like more appropriate. I am really interested in the opinions of other developers, so I sort of challenge you to come up with reasons to stick with zero-based arrays!

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about arrays

Arrays in php, Compare 2 arrays and keep duplicate values

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
The following is 2 different definitions of the problem: How can I process 2 arrays so that I can keep the data of duplicate array[key] values. I have arrays A and B. I want to create array C with the children that their id/key values exist in both A and B arrays. Thank you >>> More
commands&creating pointer [closed]

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
input 23 3 4 4 42 n 23 0 9 9 n n n 3 9 9 x //according to input,i should create int pointer arrays. pointer arrays // starting from 1 (that is initial arrays is arrays[1].when program sees n ,it // must be jumb to arrays 2 // the first int input 23 is num_arrays which used… >>> More
n & x commands&creating pointer&with using malloc [closed]

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
input 23 3 4 4 42 n 23 0 9 9 n n n 3 9 9 x //according to input,i should create int pointer arrays. pointer arrays // starting from 1 (that is initial arrays is arrays[1].when program sees n ,it // must be jumb to arrays 2 // the first int input 23 is num_arrays which… >>> More
reopen or read and say why not reopened [closed]

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
input 23 3 4 4 42 n 23 0 9 9 n n n 3 9 9 x //according to input,i should create int pointer arrays. pointer arrays // starting from 1 (that is initial arrays is arrays[1].when program sees n ,it // must be jumb to arrays 2 // the first int input 23 is num_arrays which used… >>> More
Fortran arrays and subroutines (sub arrays)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm going through a Fortran code, and one bit has me a little puzzled. There is a subroutine, say SUBROUTINE SSUB(X,...) REAL*8 X(0:N1,1:N2,0:N3-1),... ... RETURN END Which is called in another subroutine by: CALL SSUB(W(0,1,0,1),...) where W is a 'working array'. It appears that a specific… >>> More

Related posts about language-agnostic

Are there any language agnostic unit testing frameworks?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I have always been skeptical of rewriting working code - porting code is no exception to this. However, with the advent of TDD and automated testing it is much more reasonable to rewrite and refactor code. Does anyone know if there is a TDD tool that can be used for porting old code? Ideally you… >>> More
Language Agnostic Basic Programming Question

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
This is very basic question from programming point of view but as I am in learning phase, I thought I would better ask this question rather than having a misunderstanding or narrow knowledge about the topic. So do excuse me if somehow I mess it up. Question: Let's say I have class A,B,C and D… >>> More
Language-agnostic term for typed things that need memory

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Is there an accepted general term that subsumes the concepts of variables, class instances and arrays? Basically "any typed thing that needs memory". In C++, such a thing is called an object, but I'm looking for a more language-agnostic term. § 1.8 The C++ object model 1 The constructs in… >>> More
Deprecated Methods in Code Base

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
A lot of the code I've been working on recently, both professionally (read: at work) and in other spheres (read: at home, for friends/family/etc, or NOT FOR WORK), has been worked on, redesigned and re-implemented several times - where possible/required. This has been in an effort to make things smaller… >>> More
Coding Competition, language agnostic guidelines?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi there: I might be doing a coding competition soon, I was wondering if anyone made one and what where the guidelines/ process. I'd like to make the competition appealing to all devs, and I m trying to come up with ideas as to how. the scenario is: There is an event running and we(of the coding… >>> More