what is the point of heterogenous arrays?
Posted
by
aharon
on Stack Overflow
See other posts from Stack Overflow
or by aharon
Published on 2010-12-26T16:47:47Z
Indexed on
2010/12/26
16:53 UTC
Read the original article
Hit count: 314
I know that more-dynamic-than-Java languages, like Python and Ruby, often allow you to place objects of mixed types in arrays, like so:
["hello", 120, ["world"]]
What I don't understand is why you would ever use a feature like this. If I want to store heterogenous data in Java, I'll usually create an object for it.
For example, say a User
has int ID
and String name
. While I see that in Python/Ruby/PHP you could do something like this:
[["John Smith", 000], ["Smith John", 001], ...]
this seems a bit less safe/OO than creating a class User
with attributes ID
and name
and then having your array:
[<User: name="John Smith", id=000>, <User: name="Smith John", id=001>, ...]
where those <User ...>
things represent User objects.
Is there reason to use the former over the latter in languages that support it? Or is there some bigger reason to use heterogenous arrays?
N.B. I am not talking about arrays that include different objects that all implement the same interface or inherit from the same parent, e.g.:
class Square extends Shape
class Triangle extends Shape
[new Square(), new Triangle()]
because that is, to the programmer at least, still a homogenous array as you'll be doing the same thing with each shape (e.g., calling the draw()
method), only the methods commonly defined between the two.
© Stack Overflow or respective owner