What's the real benefit of meta-modeling?

Posted by Jakob on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by Jakob
Published on 2011-11-18T18:59:48Z Indexed on 2011/11/19 2:07 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 480

Filed under:

abstraction

|

modeling

|

mdd

After reading several texts about meta-modeling I still do not really get the practical benefit. Sometimes I think it is only an interesting mind game but no useful tool. Sure it is wise to clarify your modeling vocabulary: some may say class where others say entity or concept, but this is just simple documentation your modeling terminology. Meta-modeling, as I understand it, is more complex, as it tries to formalize and abstract modeling. Some good examples are Keet's formal comparison of conceptual data modeling languages (UML, ERM and ORM) from academia and the Meta Object Facility (MOF) from industry. To me MOF looks as impractical as CORBA, which was also created by OMG. In theory you could use meta-modeling to transform and integrate models in different modeling languages, but is anyone actually doing this?

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about abstraction

Is there a way communicate or measure levels of abstraction?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I'll be the first to say that this question is a bit... out there. But here are a couple questions I bear in mind : Is abstraction continuous or discrete? Is there a single unit of abstraction? But I'm not sure those questions are truly answerable or even really makes sence. My naive answer would… >>> More
What is the value in hiding the details through abstractions? Isn't there value in transparency?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
Background I am not a big fan of abstraction. I will admit that one can benefit from adaptability, portability and re-usability of interfaces etc. There is real benefit there, and I don't wish to question that, so let's ignore it. There is the other major "benefit" of abstraction, which is to hide… >>> More
Objective-C: how to prevent abstraction leaks

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I gather that in Objective-C I must declare instance variables as part of the interface of my class even if these variables are implementation details and have private access. In "subjective" C, I can declare a variable in my .c file and it is not visible outside of that compilation unit. I can declare… >>> More
How much abstraction is too much?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
In an Object Oriented Program: How much abstraction is too much? How much is just right? I have always been a nuts and bolts kind of guy. I understood the concept behind high levels of encapsulation and abstraction, but always felt instinctively that adding too much would just confuse the program… >>> More
Abstraction is for lame programmers ? [closed]

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, there's this senior developer in my company who's (in his own opinion) a pretty good C programmer. I happen to be from functional background (ML, to be specific) and so for me composition and abstraction are the two basic elements of programming. But this MrSmartyPants has got some kind of superiority… >>> More

Related posts about modeling

Data Modeling: Logical Modeling Exercise

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
In trying to learn the art of data storage I have been trying to take in as much solid information as possible. PerformanceDBA posted some really helpful tutorials/examples in the following posts among others: is my data normalized? and Relational table naming convention. I already asked a subset… >>> More
general database modeling and django specific modeling

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm wondering what is the best way to model something like the following. Lets say my company sells metal bars (parameters/fields are: length, profile_type, quantity etc.) of different profiles, where profiles may be pipe(pipe_diameter, wall_thickness) or hollow_rectangle(base, height, wall_thickness)… >>> More
"Deep Fried Bytes Podcast": Lars on SQL Server Modeling

as seen on Dot net Slackers - Search for 'Dot net Slackers'
Here's how the Deep Fried guys describe episode 45: "At PDC 2009, 'Oslo' was renamed to SQL Modeling and it left a lot of developers scratching their heads. What better way to sort it all out than to talk with someone deep into the stack. We sat down with Lars Corneliussen to see how this is all going… >>> More
SQL Server Modeling Services with Microsoft Visual Studio 2010 Beta 2

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Learn how to use SQL Modeling Services to hunt for interdependencies without having to access source code. >>> More
SQL Server Modeling Services with Microsoft Visual Studio 2010 Beta 2

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Learn how to use SQL Modeling Services to hunt for interdependencies without having to access source code. >>> More