What happens when a consumer switch receives a VLAN-tagged Ethernet frame?

Posted by netvope on Server Fault See other posts from Server Fault or by netvope
Published on 2011-11-22T20:45:20Z Indexed on 2011/11/24 1:55 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 622

Filed under:

switch

|

vlan

|

trunk

|

802.1q

Suppose you connect a trunk port from a VLAN capable network switch to a (VLAN incapable) consumer-grade network switch via a direct cable. Now the former switch send the later switch a 802.1Q-tagged Ethernet frame. What should the later switch do? Drop the frame? Forward the frame? Undefined behavior?

If the behavior is undefined, what is most probable?

Edit: Thank you for your answers. To summarize, the behavior of the consumer switch depends on:

How it handles frames with 0x8100 in the EtherType field¹
How it handles jumbo frames, or frames with payload larger than 1500 bytes

Wikipedia has a nice diagram comparing an untagged and a tagged Ethernet frame:

There are reports that some consumer-grade switches pass VLAN-tagged frames just fine.

_{¹ or more precisely, where an EtherType field is expected for non-tagged frames}

© Server Fault or respective owner

Related posts about switch

Problem connecting a 3Com 2952-Plus switch to a Cisco 3750 switch

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Connected a 3Com 2952-SFP Plus switch to a Cisco 3750 switch via fibre. There is a light on the 3Com end, but nothing at the Cisco end, and no traffic will flow. Have swapped SFP's, have swapped fibre cables, have used a different port on the Cisco, have even swapped the 3Com switch, but still no… >>> More
enable Cisco switch to communicate withe HP switch

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have one CISCO 2906g and hp 2626 switches i link them by MM fiber optic cable, the problem the cant communicate with each other, i verify there is no problem with cable and JBC's. win i connect other HP switch in the other end it will communicate without any problem, but not with CISCO >>> More
Repository pattern - Switch out the database and switch in XML files

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Repository pattern - Switch out the database and switch in XML files. Hello I have an asp.net MVC 2.0 project and I have followed the Repository pattern. Periodically, I am losing access to the database server so I want to have another mechanism in place (XML files) to continue developing. It is… >>> More
SQL Server database with clustered GUID PKs - switch clustered index or switch to sequential (comb)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
We have a database in which all the PKs are GUIDs, and most of the PKs are also the clustered index for the table. We know that this is bad (due to the random nature of GUIDs). So, it seems there are basically two options here (short of throwing out GUIDs as PKs altogether, which we cannot do (at… >>> More
MS SQL Database with clustered GUID PKs - switch clustered index or switch to sequential (comb) GUID

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
We have a database in which all the PKs are GUIDs, and most of the PKs are also the clustered index for the table. We know that this is bad (due to the random nature of GUIDs). So, it seems there are basically two options here (short of throwing out GUIDs as PKs altogether, which we cannot do (at… >>> More

Related posts about vlan

Cisco vlan entry missing in vlan.dat, but appears in running-config

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
One of our vlan's (ID: 104) stopped working suddenly and computers on that vlan failed when trying to obtain a dhcp ip address. On the Cisco switch if we do show vlan, this command is supposed to shows the vlans in the vlan.dat file. We notice it has every other vlan except the one that is now missing… >>> More
Unable to access VLAN host from VLAN interface in CentOS

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I am playing with VLAN (Virtual LAN) configuration on CentOS 6.4. I have 2 interfaces, eth0 and eth1. I have configured 2 VLAN interfaces eth0.20 and eth0.30 as #file: ifcfg-eth0.20 #------------- VLAN=yes DEVICE=eth0.20 TYPE=Ethernet ONBOOT=yes NM_CONTROLLED=no BOOTPROTO=static IPADDR=192.168… >>> More
Multiple vlans access to shared pbx system

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I'm new to networking and was looking for some assistance. First off I'm using packet tracer to diagram my scenario as I will be receiving my equipment next week to deploy. Hardware to be used: 2 catalyst 3560 switches all connect to a sonic wall router I have two companies that work in the… >>> More
VLAN ID 4095 for guest VLAN tagging

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Just want to know if it's true that if you use the VLAN ID 4095 for guest VLAN tagging, then vMotion will not work correctly as there is nowhere to pass back the reverse arp to? So, the problem we have noticed is when we have vmotioned VM's that are tagged on our trunk network, you cannot ping them… >>> More
vlan change via scvmm not working

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Hi i have a windows 2008 R2 hyper-v server which is managed via scvmm 2008 R2. the guest os running on the hyper-v server is winxp with sp3. if i change the vlan id via scvmm the guest doesn't get an ip via dhcp i looked in the properties of the vm with the hyper-v mmc an see the vlan changed correctly… >>> More