tradeoffs of iSCSI vs. AFP when using Time Machine with a NAS?

Posted by Ajit George on Super User See other posts from Super User or by Ajit George
Published on 2010-03-10T18:43:03Z Indexed on 2012/03/26 17:33 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 299

Filed under:

nas

|

time-machine

|

iscsi

|

afp

I'm setting up a home NAS device (Synology DS409) that I'm planning to use for Time Machine backups (amongst other things).

What are the tradeoffs between using iSCSI or AFP to mount the backup volume?

The Synology wiki suggests that iSCSI is better if the Mac will be frequently disconnected from the network or sleeping, from the point of view of the volume automatically remounting. What about filesystem consistency? Given that unplugging a USB drive without properly unmounting it often requires the Time Machine volume to be repaired, would iSCSI have the same issues?

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about nas

Backup NAS to another NAS?

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
hey there, is there a way to backup / transfer a NAS (it's like a big harddrive with some access to a webinterface, but closed linux etc.... only two ethernet ports) to another one? or is the only way to connect both NASs to my computer and copy the data from one to the other? it's like 750gb of… >>> More
Copying files from NAS to NAS drives

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Very simple question. I've got 2 NAS drive that are "wire" connected via a router. If I have a wireless laptop and request a large amount of data be copied from one NAS drive to the other, does the network traffic go direct from the one drive to the other, going via the wired network, or does the… >>> More
cPanel web servers mounting home partition to a NAS or SAN

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Hello, I currently have 2 cPanel web servers that are little 1RU dual cpu quad core xeons. They have a lot of resources for processing and handling web requests, and never exceed more than 10% cpu usage. They also have plenty of RAM. The problem is though that they both have RAID 1 160Gb SAS hard… >>> More
cant find nas mediaplayer on vista

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
i have a icy box ib mp3010hw media player i have it on wireless and have it connected to my tp link wr641g router and can access the radio on the net the problem i have is vista sp2 does not see it and i don't know how to go about making it find it. i ran the ping test i think it is by going through… >>> More
Qnap TS-809 NAS

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I'm looking for a portable NAS solution for around 30 servers to back up to. I require 8-16TB of space. Does anyone have any experience of the Qnap TS-809 and know if it would be suitable for this many servers to be backing up to? >>> More

Related posts about time-machine

Time machine backup on S3

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Is there any possibility to use Amazon S3 for Mac OS X time machine backups? Or in other words: Use S3 rather an external hard disk for time machine backups? >>> More
Restoring Time Machine from two Macs onto one (new) mac

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
My parents used to have two Macs...a "iLamp-style" iMac for my Dad, and an iBook G4 for my Mom. A while back, I had setup the iMac to have an external Firewire Hard Drive for a Time Machine Volume, and backed up both the iMac and iBook to that drive. Recently, the iBook died and the iMac was really… >>> More
Time machine failing to backup as sparsebundle is already in use

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I have an airport extreme with a drive connected, and use it for backing up snow leopard macs. I have an occasional problem with one of them that says "the backup disk image ... is already in use" and it fails to backup. Any ideas? >>> More
Multiple Time Machine Network Backups

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I have FreeNAS servers at work and at home. Both are set up to back up via Time Machine. Is there a way I can tell my Macbook Pro to use both without having to manually switch in the Time Machine Preferences? >>> More
Remotely sync Time Machine drives

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have an Xserve that runs Time Machine to a local terabyte drive. I also connected my external terabyte drive for a time period and had Time Machine use it to establish the seed data. I plan to take my drive back home with me (out of state) and have the Xserve return to using its local drive for… >>> More