How to stop Excel from firing Worksheet_Change before Workbook_BeforeSave?

Posted by Camil Bancioiu on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Camil Bancioiu
Published on 2012-01-11T12:38:14Z Indexed on 2012/04/05 5:30 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 174

Filed under:

excel

|

events

|

vba

Update: Issue Resolved A colleague of mine was changing a cell during Workbook_BeforeSave() without disabling events, therefore triggering Worksheet_Change(). Yes, silly, but at least it's our fault, not Excel's

I've noticed that whenever I hit Ctrl+S in Excel, the Worksheet_Change() is fired before Workbook_BeforeSave(). Is it possible to supress this behaviour using VBA code, but without supressing all events (i.e. without Application.EnableEvents = false)?

This happens regardless of what I'm doing. I've read about someone having a similar issue with ComboBoxes, but I'm not editing ComboBoxes, yet Worksheet_Change() fires always before saving.

Any ideas? I'm only trying to figure out how to bypass some code inside Worksheet_Change() when the document is saved, because that code is only supposed to be executed when the user actually changes something, not when the workbook is saved. Saving is by no means changing...

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about excel

Excel error "This workbook contains Excel 4.0 macros or Excel 5.0 modules"

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I have a workbook that was protected via the Protect Workbook feature. It was sent to someone else to modify. When they sent it back, it was unprotected and when I try to reprotect it I get this error, "This workbook contains Excel 4.0 macros or Excel 5.0 modules. If you would like to… >>> More
Open excel 2007 excel files and save as 97-2003 formats in VBA

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I have a weird situation where I have a set of excel files, all having the extension .xls., in a directory where I can open all of them just fine in Excel 2007. The odd thing is that I cannot open them in Excel 2003, on the same machine, without opening the file first in 2007 and going and saving… >>> More
Creating Excel or Excel compatible Spreadsheets on the server side in C#

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'd like to make server-side excel compatible spreadsheets that maybe use OpenXML or a structured data format. I've used Office Interop before to generate Excel spreadsheets, but those apps run on a PC that has office installed. For this web project I'm building, the server doesn't have office installed… >>> More
vba access values from excel workbook from another excel workbook

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Any ideas why this code will not work? Workbooks.Open Filename:="C:\a.xls" Workbooks("a.xls").Activate Worksheets("b").Select Dim OutputArray(10, 10) OutputArray(1, 1) = Workbooks("c.xls").Worksheets("worksheet_otherthan_default").Select.Range(A1).Value I'm trying to run a macro in one file (unnamed… >>> More
Excel workbook event order and usage when closing Excel

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Given the following workbook events: BeforeClose BeforeSave Please tell me: - The firing order in the case of multiple workbooks alreay opened (wb1, wb2 and wb3 are opened in this order) and the user closes Excel. You can assume all 3 needs saving. - What happen if user cancels one of the saving… >>> More

Related posts about events

jquery fullcalendar - viewDisplay to pass selected month to events (reload events per month)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, How can I pass the selected month from viewDisplay to the events function (which is a php call to the DB to load the events)? Only events for one month should get loaded at a time, but I'm afraid of what might happen if the user decides to click 'next' multiple times really quickly... My other… >>> More
Windows Spooler Events API doesn't generate events for network printers

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
the context i use Spooler Events API to capture events generated by the spooler when a user prints a document ie. FindFirstPrinterChangeNotification FindNextPrinterChangeNotification the problem When I print a document on the network printers from my machine no events are captured by the monitor… >>> More
attachEvent inserts events at the begin of the queue while addEventListener appends events to the qu

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I use this simple working function to add events: function AppendEvent(html_element, event_name, event_function) { if(html_element) { if(html_element.attachEvent) //IE html_element.attachEvent("on" + event_name, event_function); else if(html_element.addEventListener) //FF … >>> More
Complex SQL query help on aggregating values for nested subquery

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi! I have people, companies, employees, events and event kinds. I'm making a report/followup sheet where people, companies and employees are the rows, and the columns are event kinds. Event kinds are simple values describing: "Promised Donation", "Received Donation", "Phoned", "Followed up" and… >>> More
"power limit notification" clobbering on 12G Dell servers with RHEL6

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Server: Poweredge r620 OS: RHEL 6.4 Kernel: 2.6.32-358.18.1.el6.x86_64 I'm experiencing application alarms in my production environment. Critical CPU hungry processes are being starved of resources and causing a processing backlog. The problem is happening on all the 12th Generation Dell servers… >>> More