Do I suffer from encapsulation overuse?

Posted by Florenc on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by Florenc
Published on 2012-04-16T00:27:23Z Indexed on 2012/04/16 5:45 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 598

I have noticed something in my code in various projects that seems like code smell to me and something bad to do, but I can't deal with it.

While trying to write "clean code" I tend to over-use private methods in order to make my code easier to read. The problem is that the code is indeed cleaner but it's also more difficult to test (yeah I know I can test private methods...) and in general it seems a bad habit to me.

Here's an example of a class that reads some data from a .csv file and returns a group of customers (another object with various fields and attributes).

public class GroupOfCustomersImporter {
//... Call fields ....
public GroupOfCustomersImporter(String filePath) {

    this.filePath = filePath;

    customers = new HashSet<Customer>();

    createCSVReader();

    read();

    constructTTRP_Instance();

}

private void createCSVReader() {
    //....
}

private void read() {
    //.... Reades the file and initializes the class attributes
}

private void readFirstLine(String[] inputLine) {
    //.... Method used by the read() method
}

private void readSecondLine(String[] inputLine) {
    //.... Method used by the read() method
}

private void readCustomerLine(String[] inputLine) { 
    //.... Method used by the read() method
}

private void constructGroupOfCustomers() {
    //this.groupOfCustomers = new GroupOfCustomers(**attributes of the class**);
}

public GroupOfCustomers getConstructedGroupOfCustomers() {
    return this.GroupOfCustomers;
}

}

As you can see the class has only a constructor which calls some private methods to get the job done, I know that's not a good practice not a good practice in general but I prefer to encapsulate all the functionality in the class instead of making the methods public in which case a client should work this way:

GroupOfCustomersImporter importer = new GroupOfCustomersImporter(filepath)
importer.createCSVReader();
read();
GroupOfCustomer group = constructGoupOfCustomerInstance();

I prefer this because I don't want to put useless lines of code in the client's side code bothering the client class with implementation details.

So, Is this actually a bad habit? If yes, how can I avoid it? Please note that the above is just a simple example. Imagine the same situation happening in something a little bit more complex.

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about design-patterns

Related posts about object-oriented-design