Why is an Ext4 disk check so much faster than NTFS?

Posted by Brendan Long on Super User See other posts from Super User or by Brendan Long
Published on 2011-03-11T18:08:24Z Indexed on 2012/06/20 21:18 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 193

Filed under:

filesystems

|

ntfs

|

ext4

|

check-disk

I had a situation today where I restarted my computer and it said I needed to check the disk for consistancy. About 10 minutes later (at "1%" complete), I gave up and decided to let it run when I go home.

For comparison, my home computer uses Ext4 for all of the partitions, and the disk checks (which run around once week) only take a couple seconds. I remember reading that having fast disk checks was a priority, but I don't know how they could do that.

So, how does Ext4 do disk checks so fast? Is there some huge breakthrough in doing this after NTFS came out (~10 years ago)?

Note: The NTFS disk is ~300 GB and the Ext4 disk is ~500 GB. Both are about half full.

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about filesystems

Question regarding filesystems true or false?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Hello all, though I'm familiar with stackoverflow , and loving it , i've actually got a couple of questions myself about something other then programming. Here are my question Is it true that in FAT filesystems the maximum number of files per filesystem equals the number of entries in the FAT table… >>> More
Filesystems for webserver with SATA and Solid State disk,

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
We have just ordered a new webserver with 120 Gb solid state disk and a SATA disk. I am trying to plan ahead what sort of filesystem to use. This system will be running Linux, Apache/Tomcat to host java services. The main service is a system where people can upload reasonably large files (in the… >>> More
To see virtual filesystems in Ubuntu

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
How can you see the virtual filesystems at root? They should be /proc and /dev. >>> More
How do filesystems handle concurrent read/write?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
User A asks the system to read file foo and at the same time user B wants to save his or her data onto the same file. How is this situation handled on the filesystem level? >>> More
Strange ZFS hidden filesystem problem

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Half of my ZFS filesystems are hidden in ZFS-fuse. Here's my story: So, I love ZFS. I used it for about six months on FreeBSD, but due to it crashing the kernel during heavy inter-filesystem IO load, I tried switching to Solaris 5.10. That was good, but when I attempted to do an import of my Version… >>> More

Related posts about ntfs

NTFS and NTFS-3G

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I have a netbook with Ubuntu Netbook 10.04 and a desktop with Mint 10 (~ Ubuntu Desktop 10.10) Both of them have read/write NTFS partitions mounted via /etc/fstab. And it works fine. Ive read on net, google, forums, and several posts here, that NTFS-3G is the driver that allows you to have full… >>> More
NTFS partitions hidden under EXT4 file system / partition...want to recover files from NTFS

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I am new to ubuntu, but very impressed with the system. so one day i tried installing ubuntu 10.10 along with windows in dual boot first place it didnt get installed properly and during second attempt i could do it right but oh...i lost my windows 7 , here is my problem and what i have done till… >>> More
Kernel NTFS driver vs NTFS-3G

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
A more comprehensive phrased question since I lost access to the other one. I would ask that the other one be deleted, not this one, as it should not have been migrated in the first place. There are currently two NTFS drivers available for Linux. The NTFS driver included in the kernel, and the… >>> More
NTFS partitions hidden under EXT4 file system / partion...want to recover files from NTFS

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
Hi all, I am new to ubuntu, but very impressed with the system. so one day i tried installing ubuntu 10.10 along with windows in dual boot first place it didnt get installed properly and during second attempt i could do it right but oh...i lost my windows 7 , here is my problem and what i have done… >>> More
Can't write to NTFS formatted drives

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I'm not sure what has happened, but I've all of a sudden lost write access to any of my NTFS external drives. I installed a few games and apps from the software center, and now I can't make new folders or copy and paste files to anything that is NTFS. Everything is now read only, and I've tried… >>> More