How to encrypt dual boot windows 7 and xp (bitlocker, truecrypt combo?) on sdd (recommended?)

Posted by therobyouknow on Super User See other posts from Super User or by therobyouknow
Published on 2012-08-27T02:06:41Z Indexed on 2012/08/28 9:41 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 270

I would like to setup a dual boot Windows 7 and Windows XP laptop/notebook computer where each operation system's partition is fully encrypted. I would like to do this on a SSD - a 128Gb Crucial M4.

My research

Dual boot of truecrypt encrypted OSs on one drive (not possible - in Truecript 7.x at time of writing)

This cannot be done on a standard Truecrypt setup - it will only support encrypting one of the operating systems. I have tried this and also read about it here on superuser.com

However, I did see a solution here that uses grub4dos as the initial bootloader to chain to separate truecrypt encrypted OSs, in my case Windows 7 and Windows XP: http://yyzyyz.blogspot.co.uk/2010/06/truecrypt-how-to-encrypt-multiple.html

I am not going to consider this solution as it relies upon some custom code for use in the bootloader that is provided by the author. I would prefer a solution that can be fully understood so that I can be sure that there is nothing undesirable occuring (i.e. malware or just simply bugs in the code). I would like to believe such a solution doesn't have those risks but I can't be sure.

BitLocker and Truecrypt combination - possible solution?

So I am now considering a combination of encryption programs: I now aim to encrypt Windows XP with Truecrypt and Windows 7 with BitLocker. Assuming Truecrypt bootloader can boot into non-Truecrypt OSs (e.g. via hitting Escape to go to another menu), then this solution may be viable.

SSDs and Encryption (use fastest possible spinning hard disk instead (?))

I read on various superuser.com posts and elsewhere that current SSDs are not suited to whole drive encryption for various reasons:

  • impact of performance algorithms that give SSDs advantage over spinning harddisks. Algorithms used in compression of data for example.

  • Wear on the SSD, shortening its life

  • Security issues whereby data is repeated, as indicated in some Truecrypt documentation

So I am now considering not using SSD. But with the aim to have the fastest drive possible, I am considering using the Western Digital Scorpion black 2.5" 7200rpm harddisk as this appears to be top rated among spinning platter-based harddrives (don't work for Western Digital).

Summary

So to achieve whole drive encrypted dual boot Windows 7 and Windows XP with minimal performance impact I intend to use a combination of Truecrypt and Bitlocker on a top-rated conventional spinning platter-based harddisk.

Questions

Will my summary:

  • achieve whole disk encryption of the dual-boot Windows XP, Windows 7? OR an you suggest a simpler solution, including one that only requires only Truecrypt (BitLocker not available on XP). Or another encryption tool, including paid-for?
  • provide the highest performance. Am I correct to avoid using SDD with encryption for the reasons I discovered? Are the concerns about SSDs and encryption still very real (some articles I read go back to 2010)

Thanks for your input!

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about Performance

Related posts about ssd