What is the difference between _Procedural Generation_ and _Random Generation_?

Posted by U-No-Poo on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by U-No-Poo
Published on 2012-12-19T10:10:11Z Indexed on 2012/12/20 5:13 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 227

Filed under:

random

|

procedural

Today, I got into an argument about the term "procedural generation".

My point was that its different from "classic" random generation in that procedural generation is based on a more mathematical, fractal-based, algorithm leading to a more "realistic" distribution and the usual randomness of most languages are based on a pseudo-random-number generator, leading to an "unrealistic", in a way, ugly, distribution. This discussion was made with a heightmap in mind.

The discussion left me somehow unconvinced about my own arguments though, so, is there more to it? Or am I the one who is, in fact, simply wrong?

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about random

Text inside <p> shrinks on mobile devices while div does not [migrated]

as seen on Pro Webmasters - Search for 'Pro Webmasters'
I asked this question on stack overflow, but didn't get any answers, so I'm trying here. Does anybody know whats happening here? I tested on opera, dolphin and the factory android browser. (although it seems now to be working on opera) The div doesn't change size, but the text somehow is shrunk… >>> More
Random Movement for multiple entities

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
I have this code for a arraylist of entities. All the entities use the same random and so all of them move in the same direction. How can I change it so it generates a new random number for each entity? public void moveFemale() { for(int i = 0; i < 1000; i++){ random = rand.nextInt(99); … >>> More
Python: Random is barely random at all?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I did this to test the randomness of randint: >>> from random import randint >>> >>> uniques = [] >>> for i in range(4500): # You can see I optimistic. ... x = randint(500, 5000) ... if x in uniques: ... raise Exception('We duped ' + str(x) + '… >>> More
Why is Random class isn't really random?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I've read about it on a message board - Random class isn't really random. It is created with predictable fashion using a mathematical formula. Is it really true? If so, Random isn't really random?? >>> More
c++ generate a good random seed for psudo random number generators

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I am trying to generate a good random seed for a psudo-random number generator. I thought I'd get the expert's opinions. let me know if this is a bad way of doing it or if there are much better ways. #include <iostream> #include <cstdlib> #include <fstream> #include <ctime> unsigned… >>> More

Related posts about procedural

PHP: procedural vs non-procedural approach

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, Rasmus Lerdorf (creator of php) advocates procedural style where as most successful way has turned out to be non-procedural. What is the benefit of procedural over non-procedural approach at last? Why does he advocate that? >>> More
Procedural, Semi-Procedural and Declarative Programing Part II

as seen on Simple Talk - Search for 'Simple Talk'
SQL Server accommodates a whole range of programming styles and will even allow you to create code that is wholly procedural. Is a declarative approach inevitably better? Can it be difficult to maintain? Can you avoid the performance problems of procedural code by using triggers? Joe adds some thoughts… >>> More
Procedural, Semi-Procedural and Declarative Programming in SQL

as seen on SQL Server Central - Search for 'SQL Server Central'
A lot of the time, the key to making SQL databases perform well is to take a break from the keyboard and rethink the way of approaching the problem; and rethinking in terms of a set-based declarative approach. Joe takes a simple discussion abut a problem with a UDF to illustrate the point that ingrained… >>> More
Procedural, Semi-Procedural and Declarative Programming in SQL

as seen on Simple Talk - Search for 'Simple Talk'
A lot of the time, the key to making SQL databases perform well is to take a break from the keyboard and rethink the way of approaching the problem; and rethinking in terms of a set-based declarative approach. Joe takes a simple discussion abut a problem with a UDF to illustrate the point that ingrained… >>> More
I need books for procedural programming

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
Please suggest books for procedural programming. I need to know the core principles/patterns of procedural programming. So it doesn't matter if the book using any language to convey the procedural programming principles, be it pure C or others languages. Nowadays it is difficult to find ones. Even… >>> More