Is it necessary to read every single byte to check if a copied file is identical to the original?

Posted by Koen027 on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by Koen027
Published on 2011-12-03T15:08:28Z Indexed on 2013/06/27 22:28 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 444

Filed under:

difference

|

file-handling

I recently learned of a program called Total Commander. It's a Windows Explorer replacement and has its own stuff to copy files. To check whether the files are identical, instead of calculation a CRC, it literally checks every single byte, one at a time, on both the original and the copy.

My question is: Is this necessary? Can CRC or any other such technique go wrong? Should you, as a programmer, try and implement this perfect but slow system, or is it too extreme?

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about difference

Difference between Website and Web Application in ASP.NET

as seen on Samir ASP.NET with C# Technology - Search for 'Samir ASP.NET with C# Technology'
Web site in Visual Studio 2005: A web site is just a group of all files in a folder and sub folders. There is no project file. All files under the specific folder - including your word documents, text files, images etc are part of the web site. You have to deploy all files including source… >>> More
Is it necessary to read every single byte to check if a copied file is identical to the original?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I recently learned of a program called Total Commander. It's a Windows Explorer replacement and has its own stuff to copy files. To check whether the files are identical, instead of calculation a CRC, it literally checks every single byte, one at a time, on both the original and the copy. My question… >>> More
Can I configure a visual difference view with the notifications provided by TFS?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I have TFS sending me alerts whenever someone on my team checks in code. (I had to create notification rules for every project, but that's just a sidebar complaint in this question.) These alerts provided some information on who checked in the files when, and what files have changed, with urls to… >>> More
Difference between a pseudo code and algorithm?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
Technically, Is there a difference between these two words or can we use them interchangeably? Both of them more or less describe the logical sequence of steps that follow in solving a problem. ain't it? SO why do we actually use two such words if they are meant to talk of the same? Or, In case if… >>> More
What difference with Android when iOS is not open?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
My question may seem silly, but, I've read in many Android books that the better part of Android is Android is open, and iOS is closed. But, from a programmer viewpoint, who cares about this point? Programmers just care about the platform: is it easy to program in, easy to have help in the network… >>> More

Related posts about file-handling

feof() in C file handling

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I am reading a binary file byte-by-byte,i need determine that whether or not eof has reached. feof() doesn't works as "eof is set only when a read request for non-existent byte is made". So, I can have my custom check_eof like: if ( fread(&byte,sizeof(byte),1,fp) != 1) { if(feof()) return… >>> More
file handling in vb.net

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello there I have developed an application in vb.net2008 and database sqlserver. Now i want to ignore the database(it has 1 table as customer(name,password,hour,minute)) as i dont want my client to install sqlserver separately or other overheads. I am planning to do the whole using file handling… >>> More
Best way XML File handling bullet point •

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
For an XML file I am creating I have data that contains a bullet • what is the best method for handling this in xml data? It opens in an XML editor and reads fine, but I cannot import the file via SSIS, I get an error regarding this point. <xmldata>• Bullet</xmldata> Renders fine,… >>> More
VI/VIM file handling

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Nowa days I'm working with the Vi editor with the positive approach that you can do most things using it - unlike other editors. I came across one problem: Let's assume I have open a folder with vi <folder name> so it opens the folder in Vi and lists the files in that folder. I select a… >>> More
Having problem with C++ file handling

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Our lecturer has given us a task,I've attempted it and try every single effort I can,but I still struggle with one of the problem in it,here goes the question: The company you work at receives a monthly report in a text format. The report contains the following information. • Department Name • Head… >>> More