IO::Pipe - close(<handle>) does not set $?
- by danboo
My understanding is that closing the handle for an IO::Pipe object should be done with the method ($fh->close) and not the built-in (close($fh)).
The other day I goofed and used the built-in out of habit on a IO::Pipe object that was opened to a command that I expected to fail. I was surprised when $? was zero, and my error checking wasn't triggered.
I realized my mistake. If I use the built-in, IO:Pipe can't perform the waitpid() and can't set $?. But what I was surprised by was that perl seemed to still close the pipe without setting $? via the core.
I worked up a little test script to show what I mean:
use 5.012;
use warnings;
use IO::Pipe;
say 'init pipes:';
pipes();
my $fh = IO::Pipe->reader(q(false));
say 'post open pipes:';
pipes();
say 'return: ' . $fh->close;
#say 'return: ' . close($fh);
say 'status: ' . $?;
say q();
say 'post close pipes:';
pipes();
sub pipes
{
for my $fd ( glob("/proc/self/fd/*") )
{
say readlink($fd) if -p $fd;
}
say q();
}
When using the method it shows the pipe being gone after the close and $? is set as I expected:
init pipes:
post open pipes:
pipe:[992006]
return: 1
status: 256
post close pipes:
And, when using the built-in it also appears to close the pipe, but does not set $?:
init pipes:
post open pipes:
pipe:[952618]
return: 1
status: 0
post close pipes:
It seems odd to me that the built-in results in the pipe closure, but doesn't set $?. Can anyone help explain the discrepancy?
Thanks!
