Was reading through some articles on
the advantages of creating Generic Repositories for a new app (example).
The idea seems nice because it lets me use
the same repository to do several things for several different entity types at once:
IRepository repo = new EfRepository(); // Would normally pass through IOC into constructor
var c1 = new Country() { Name = "United States", CountryCode = "US" };
var c2 = new Country() { Name = "Canada", CountryCode = "CA" };
var c3 = new Country() { Name = "Mexico", CountryCode = "MX" };
var p1 = new Province() { Country = c1, Name = "Alabama", Abbreviation = "AL" };
var p2 = new Province() { Country = c1, Name = "Alaska", Abbreviation = "AK" };
var p3 = new Province() { Country = c2, Name = "Alberta", Abbreviation = "AB" };
repo.Add<Country>(c1);
repo.Add<Country>(c2);
repo.Add<Country>(c3);
repo.Add<Province>(p1);
repo.Add<Province>(p2);
repo.Add<Province>(p3);
repo.Save();
However,
the rest of
the implementation of
the Repository has a heavy reliance on Linq:
IQueryable<T> Query();
IList<T> Find(Expression<Func<T,bool>> predicate);
T Get(Expression<Func<T,bool>> predicate);
T First(Expression<Func<T,bool>> predicate);
//... and so on
This repository pattern worked fantastic for Entity Framework, and pretty much offered a 1 to 1 mapping of
the methods available on DbContext/DbSet. But given
the slow uptake of Linq on other data access technologies outside of Entity Framework, what advantage does this provide over working directly with
the DbContext?
I attempted to write a PetaPoco version of
the Repository, but PetaPoco doesn't support Linq Expressions, which makes creating a generic IRepository interface pretty much useless unless you only use it for
the basic GetAll, GetById, Add, Update, Delete, and Save methods and utilize it as a base class. Then you have to create specific repositories with specialized methods to handle all
the "where" clauses that I could previously pass in as a predicate.
Is
the Generic Repository pattern useful for anything outside of Entity Framework? If not, why would someone use it at all instead of working directly with Entity Framework?
Edit: Original link doesn't reflect
the pattern I was using in my sample code. Here is an (updated link).
