For the last few days, I've been trying out the new preferred approach for using QThreads without subclassing QThread. The trouble I'm having is when I try to shutdown a set of threads that I created. I regularly get a "Destroyed while thread is still running" message (if I'm running in Debug mode, I also get a Segmentation Fault dialog). My code is very simple, and I've tried to follow the examples that I've been able to find on the internet.
My basic setup is as follows: I've a simple class that I want to run in a separate thread; in fact, I want to run 5 instances of this class, each in a separate thread. I have a simple dialog with a button to start each thread, and a button to stop each thread (10 buttons). When I click one of the "start" buttons, a new instance of the test class is created, a new QThread is created, a movetothread is called to get the test class object to the thread...also, since I have a couple of other members in the test class that need to move to the thread, I call movetothread a few additional times with these other items. Note that one of these items is a QUdpSocket, and although this may not make sense, I wanted to make sure that sockets could be moved to a separate thread in this fashion...I haven't tested the use of the socket in the thread at this point.
Starting of the threads all seem to work fine. When I use the linux top command to see if the threads are created and running, they show up as expected.
The problem occurs when I begin stopping the threads. I randomly (or it appears to be random) get the error described above.
Class that is to run in separate thread:
// Declaration
class TestClass : public QObject
{
Q_OBJECT
public:
explicit TestClass(QObject *parent = 0);
QTimer m_workTimer;
QUdpSocket m_socket;
Q_SIGNALS:
void finished();
public Q_SLOTS:
void start();
void stop();
void doWork();
};
// Implementation
TestClass::TestClass(QObject *parent) :
QObject(parent)
{
}
void TestClass::start()
{
connect(&m_workTimer, SIGNAL(timeout()),this,SLOT(doWork()));
m_workTimer.start(50);
}
void TestClass::stop()
{
m_workTimer.stop();
emit finished();
}
void TestClass::doWork()
{
int j;
for(int i = 0; i<10000; i++)
{
j = i;
}
}
Inside my main app, code called to start the first thread (similar code exists for each of the other threads):
mp_thread1 = new QThread();
mp_testClass1 = new TestClass();
mp_testClass1->moveToThread(mp_thread1);
mp_testClass1->m_socket.moveToThread(mp_thread1);
mp_testClass1->m_workTimer.moveToThread(mp_thread1);
connect(mp_thread1, SIGNAL(started()), mp_testClass1, SLOT(start()));
connect(mp_testClass1, SIGNAL(finished()), mp_thread1, SLOT(quit()));
connect(mp_testClass1, SIGNAL(finished()), mp_testClass1, SLOT(deleteLater()));
connect(mp_testClass1, SIGNAL(finished()), mp_thread1, SLOT(deleteLater()));
connect(this,SIGNAL(stop1()),mp_testClass1,SLOT(stop()));
mp_thread1->start();
Also inside my main app, this code is called when a stop button is clicked for a specific thread (in this case thread 1):
emit stop1();
Sometimes it appears that threads are stopped and destroyed without issue. Other times, I get the error described above.
Any guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks,
Bryan
