Shawn Wildermuth violating MVVM in MSDN article?

Posted by rasx on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by rasx
Published on 2010-03-21T20:21:43Z Indexed on 2010/03/21 21:11 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 640

Filed under:
|
|
|

This may be old news but back in March 2009, Shawn Wildermuth, his article, “Model-View-ViewModel In Silverlight 2 Apps,” has a code sample that includes DataServiceEntityBase:

// COPIED FROM SILVERLIGHTCONTRIB Project for simplicity

/// <summary>
/// Base class for DataService Data Contract classes to implement 
/// base functionality that is needed like INotifyPropertyChanged.  
/// Add the base class in the partial class to add the implementation.
/// </summary>
public abstract class DataServiceEntityBase : INotifyPropertyChanged
{
/// <summary>
/// The handler for the registrants of the interface's event 
/// </summary>
PropertyChangedEventHandler _propertyChangedHandler;

/// <summary>
/// Allow inheritors to fire the event more simply.
/// </summary>
/// <param name="propertyName"></param>
protected void FirePropertyChanged(string propertyName)
{
  if (_propertyChangedHandler != null)
  {
    _propertyChangedHandler(this, new PropertyChangedEventArgs(propertyName));
  }
}

#region INotifyPropertyChanged Members
/// <summary>
/// The interface used to notify changes on the entity.
/// </summary>
event PropertyChangedEventHandler INotifyPropertyChanged.PropertyChanged
{
  add
  {
    _propertyChangedHandler += value;
  }
  remove
  {
    _propertyChangedHandler -= value;
  }
}
#endregion

What this class implies is that the developer intends to bind visuals directly to data (yes, a ViewModel is used but it defines an ObservableCollection of data objects). Is this design diverging too far from the guidance of MVVM? Now I can see some of the reasons why Shawn would go this way: what Shawn can do with DataServiceEntityBase is this sort of thing (which is intimate with the Entity Framework):

// Partial Method to support the INotifyPropertyChanged interface
public partial class Game : DataServiceEntityBase
{
    #region Partial Method INotifyPropertyChanged Implementation
    // Override the Changed partial methods to implement the 
    // INotifyPropertyChanged interface

    // This helps with the Model implementation to be a mostly
    // DataBound implementation

    partial void OnDeveloperChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("Developer"); }
    partial void OnGenreChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("Genre"); }
    partial void OnListPriceChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ListPrice"); }
    partial void OnListPriceCurrencyChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ListPriceCurrency"); }
    partial void OnPlayerInfoChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("PlayerInfo"); }
    partial void OnProductDescriptionChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ProductDescription"); }
    partial void OnProductIDChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ProductID"); }
    partial void OnProductImageUrlChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ProductImageUrl"); }
    partial void OnProductNameChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ProductName"); }
    partial void OnProductTypeIDChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ProductTypeID"); }
    partial void OnPublisherChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("Publisher"); }
    partial void OnRatingChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("Rating"); }
    partial void OnRatingUrlChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("RatingUrl"); }
    partial void OnReleaseDateChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("ReleaseDate"); }
    partial void OnSystemNameChanged() { base.FirePropertyChanged("SystemName"); }
    #endregion
}

Of course MSDN code can seen as “toy code” for educational purposes but is anyone doing anything like this in the real world of Silverlight development?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about Silverlight

Related posts about entity-framework