I'm trying to figure out how I can successfully determine if two generic type values are equal to each other. Based on Mark Byers' answer on this question I would think I can just use value.Equals() where value is a generic type.
My actual problem is in a LinkedList implementation, but the problem can be shown with this simpler example.
class GenericOjbect<T> {
public T Value { get; private set; }
public GenericOjbect(T value) {
Value = value;
}
public bool Equals(T value) {
return (Value.Equals(value));
}
}
Now I define an instance of GenericObject<StringBuilder> containing new StringBuilder("StackOverflow"). I would expect to get true if I call Equals(new StringBuilder("StackOverflow") on this GenericObject instance, but I get false.
A sample program showing this:
using System;
using System.Text;
class Program
{
static void Main()
{
var sb1 = new StringBuilder("StackOverflow");
var sb2 = new StringBuilder("StackOverflow");
Console.WriteLine("StringBuilder compare");
Console.WriteLine("1. == " + (sb1 == sb2));
Console.WriteLine("2. Object.Equals " + (Object.Equals(sb1, sb2)));
Console.WriteLine("3. this.Equals " + (sb1.Equals(sb2)));
var go1 = new GenericOjbect<StringBuilder>(sb1);
var go2 = new GenericOjbect<StringBuilder>(sb2);
Console.WriteLine("\nGenericObject compare");
Console.WriteLine("1. == " + (go1 == go2));
Console.WriteLine("2. Object.Equals " + (Object.Equals(go1, go2)));
Console.WriteLine("3. this.Equals " + (go1.Equals(go2)));
Console.WriteLine("4. Value.Equals " + (go1.Value.Equals(go2.Value)));
}
}
For the three methods of comparing two StringBuilder objects, only the StringBuilder.Equals instance method (the third line) returns true. This is what I expected. But when comparing the GenericObject objects, its Equals() method (the third line) returns false. Interestingly enough, the fourth compare method does return true. I'd think the third and fourth comparison are actually doing the same thing.
I would have expected true. Because in the Equals() method of the GenericObject class, both value and Value are of type T which in this case is a StringBuilder. Based on Mark Byers' answer in this question, I would've expected the Value.Equals() method to be using the StringBuilder's Equals() method. And as I've shown, the StringBuilder's Equal() method does return true.
I've even tried
public bool Equals(T value) {
return EqualityComparer<T>.Default.Equals(Value, value);
}
but that also returns false.
So, two questions here:
Why doesn't the code return true?
How could I implement the Equals method so it does return true?
