Pythonic Java. Yes, or no?
- by OscarRyz
Python use of indentation for code scope was initially very polemic and now is considered one of the best language features, because it helps ( almost by forcing us ) to have a consistent style.
Well, I saw this post http://bit.ly/hmvTe9 where someone posted Java code with ; y {} aligned to the right margin to look more pythonic.
It was very shocking at first ( as a matter of fact, if I ever see Java code like that in one of my projects I would be scared! ) However, there is something interesting here. Do we need all those braces and semicolons? How would the code would look like without them?
class Person
int age
void greet( String a )
if( a == "" )
out.println("Hello stranger")
else
out.printf("Hello %s%n", a )
int age()
return this.age
class Main
void main()
new Person().greet("")
Looks good to me, but in such small piece of code is hard to appreciate it, and since I don't Python too much, I can't tell by looking at existing libraries if it would be cleaner or not. So I took the first file of a library named: jAlarms I found and this is the result: ( WARNING : the following image may be disturbing for some people )
http://pxe.pastebin.com/eU1R4xsh
Obviously it doesn't compile. This would be a compiling version using right aligned {} and ;
http://pxe.pastebin.com/2uijtbYM
Question
What would happen if we could code like this? Would it make things clearer? Would it make it harder?
I see braces, and semicolons as help to the parser and we, as humans have get used to them, but do we really need them?
I guess is hard to tell specially since many mainstream languages do use braces, C, C++, Java, C# JavaScript
Assuming the compiler wouldn't have problems without them, would you use them?
Please comment.
